The IntelliCAD Network
AutoCAD Scale Nightmare
Having recently built my house using AutoCAD as one of the CAD systems, I can relate to this story. A UK couple who are building their 1 million pound dream home are fighting a battle with authorities who are looking to tear it down - all because the blue prints were automatically scaled down by 4 percent to fit the page.
"When the plans have been printed out, we didn't realise the printer had reduced them by 4 per cent and these were the plans that were passed", said Colin Walker, the 50 year old owner of the house. "The trouble is that the plans were drawn up with AutoCAD and it's dangerous to use a scale ruler because printers often have these discrepancies with computer aided design. This is why the plans clearly state that all the dimensions should be checked or measured on site and not scaled from the drawing. However, plans containing full dimensions were subsequently submitted to West Lancs building control."
Unfortunately, the plans approved were the original scaled down drawings and the authorities are now taking the stand that Walker is building a house 4 percent larger than what they approved. Walker has already lost an appeal against the enforcement notice and now hopes that the High Court will stop the demolition of his four bedroom home. Apart from the scale problem, there are 15 other discrepancies between the approved plans and the currently built structure. I wish him luck.
Comment
-
Comment by MJ on July 14, 2009 at 4:25am -
I am amazed.... whatever happened to the phrase "Do not scale from drawing. use figured dimensions only."
That was one of the first things I was ever thought in a drawing office.
Seems to me that the local council messed up along with the printer and possibly the architect (after all, it is his job to make sure that the planning application is correct), but I fail to see how the council has a leg to stand on if the drawings were correctly dimensioned in the first place.
About
Badge
© 2010 Created by Deelip Menezes on Ning. Create a Ning Network!
You need to be a member of IntelliCAD.net to add comments!
Join IntelliCAD.net